Regrettable Retention

For years, we congratulated executives on low turnover. A stable team looked like a healthy team. But have we been reading the scoreboard wrong all along?

Staff retention is a balancing act, and I agree that it is impossible to get it right. At one end there is a revolving door. At the other is declining turnover year on year.

Most leaders fear the first. Far fewer worry about the second, yet it can do just as much damage. It simply takes longer to show.

Thirty years in the same chair

I know of a business that has had the same Head of Marketing for close to 30 years. Loyal, well-liked by those at the top, part of the furniture. You only need to look at their latest social media post to see the problem. The 1990s are still barking into the abyss.

This didn't happen by accident. The Head of Marketing is well connected at the top, and those connections have protected the role even as it costs the business revenue. Each year, leaving her in the role felt easier than admitting she was out of her depth. No one wanted the awkward conversation, or to be the leader who pushed out someone with decades of service.

So the market moved, the channels changed, the audience changed, and the role stood still. The business kept paying for marketing. It stopped getting it.

Staying too long costs both sides

Turnover gets treated as a failure metric. Some of it is. Some of it is how organisations breathe. New people bring fresh insight, new ideas and the outside view that long-tenured teams lose. Stand in front of the mountain long enough and you stop seeing it.

People rarely cruise in a role forever without consequence. They drift behind the work, then behind their peers, then behind the market. Eventually a restructure does what leaders avoided for years, and the person is discarded at the worst possible moment, with skills that no longer travel.

That is the regrettable part. Carrying someone feels kind at the time. Over the years it strips them of the very options an earlier, honest conversation would have protected.

The organisation pays as well. A tenured leader who hasn't been challenged sets the ceiling for everyone below them. Talented people look up, see a role that won't open or evolve, and take their ambition elsewhere. The business keeps the person it should have refreshed and loses the people it should have kept.

Australia has stopped moving

The risk is higher right now because people aren't changing jobs. The Australian HR Institute's September Quarter 2026 Work Outlook put average annual turnover at 13.4 per cent, down from 15.2 per cent in 2025 and close to its lowest recorded level. ABS data shows just 7.2 per cent of employed Australians changed employer in the year to February 2026, down from 7.7 per cent the year before.

True, a large component of this is reflective of the uncertainty in the economy. Businesses are collapsing faster than a flat-pack wardrobe built without the instructions. But when turnover remains low for long enough, caution hardens into habit. People who would normally have moved on stay put, leaders stop asking whether each role still fits, and a temporary market condition becomes a permanent staffing decision that no one consciously made.

When the labour market does the churning for you, stale roles get refreshed by default. When it stops, renewal becomes a leadership decision. Many executive teams haven't noticed the shift. They read low turnover as health while capability ages in place.

Gartner has flagged the same risk from another angle, urging organisations to act before key skills erode as work changes. A role that hasn't been refreshed in a decade is a skills erosion problem with a name badge.

I see this all the time in succession plans. Instead of looking ahead strategically and assessing the skills the business will need, HR puts together leave and retirement plans: documents that nominate who will keep the seat warm when Barry finally clocks out for the last time, or Sally takes that 12-month, all-inclusive, round-the-world cruise. But that's an article for another day.

Drawing the line without shooting Bambi

Most leaders I work with know exactly who they're carrying. What stops them from doing anything about it is the feeling that it would be like shooting Bambi. The line becomes clearer when you separate the person from the role. Four questions help:

  1. Has the role changed in the last five years while the person in it hasn't?

  2. Would we hire this person into this role today, knowing what it now demands?

  3. Are others compensating for, redoing or working around their output?

  4. Have we told them clearly what the role requires, invested in their development and given them a genuine chance to meet these expectations?

Question four is where most organisations fall hardest. Leaders avoid the conversation for years, then compress it into a redundancy. That is the least humane path available, even if it feels safest for the leader.

Drawing the line well follows a simple sequence. Name the gap early and specifically. Set a clear standard and a realistic timeframe. Invest properly in closing it, whether through development, a stretch project or a different role where their experience counts. If the gap still doesn't close, help them leave with dignity and with skills that still have value wherever they go next.

The conversation itself doesn't need to be brutal, and it should never land as a surprise ultimatum. If the business hasn't invested in someone's growth, part of the gap belongs to leadership. Something like "The role has moved, and we haven't done enough to help you move with it. Here's what it needs now, here's what we'll put behind you, and here's how we'll both know it's working" respects the person's history while being honest about the future. Most people already sense the gap. What hurts them is discovering everyone else saw it too and said nothing.

When years served outrank value added

If your performance framework rewards tenure over contribution, your organisation is manufacturing the problem.

The pattern runs deep in government and for-purpose organisations. Long tenure is celebrated, roles are tightly held, and difficult conversations get deferred. Then a new CEO arrives or a restructure lands, and people who could have been developed or supported to move on years earlier are shown the door, often amid resistance and tears.

Loyalty deserves recognition. Anyone who has given 30 years to a community or a cause has earned the cake, the speech and the framed certificate.

Turning loyalty into momentum

Retention only becomes regrettable when it happens by default. Investing in people is a good thing when they are growing, contributing and still the right fit for where the organisation is heading. Three habits make that far more likely.

Talk about the future often and consistently. People can't grow towards a direction they've never heard. When leaders speak regularly about where the organisation is going and what it will need, long-serving staff can see the gap for themselves well before anyone has to point it out.

Make the invitation to grow and learn explicit. Development shouldn't be a reward for high performers or a remedy for poor ones. Offer it to everyone, especially those whose roles have evolved the most, and treat a declined invitation as useful information.

Back the intrapreneurs. Some of your most experienced people know exactly where the inefficiencies, workarounds and untapped opportunities sit. Give them room to think like owners: to test ideas, improve processes and build something new inside the business. Set clear boundaries on budget, decision rights and risk, so initiative doesn't drift into freelancing.

Retention is worth celebrating when people stay because they are still growing. Otherwise, all you've retained is the regret.

Previous
Previous

Enough with the Spaghetti Towers!

Next
Next

Stop Telling Leaders To Be More Human